Investigation of Epidemic: An Integrated Public Health Approach

Introduction

An epidemic is defined as the occurrence of disease cases in a community or region clearly in excess of normal expectancy for a specific period. Statistically, an epidemic is often identified when the number of cases exceeds two standard deviations above the mean of historical data. Sometimes, even a single case can constitute an epidemic if the disease is rare or eradicated in that region, such as poliomyelitis.

Types of Epidemics

Epidemics can be classified based on their source and pattern of spread:

• Common Source Epidemic: All cases are exposed to the same infection source. This includes:
  • Point Source: Single-time exposure; curve shows sharp rise and fall. Example: Food poisoning after a wedding.
  • Continuous Source: Ongoing exposure; curve shows plateau. Example: Cholera from a contaminated water source.
• Propagated Epidemic: Person-to-person spread, multiple waves in epidemic curve. Examples: COVID-19, measles.
• Mixed Epidemic: Initial common source followed by propagated transmission. Example: Cholera initially from water, then person-to-person spread.
• Slow/Modern Epidemic: Non-communicable diseases with gradual increase over time, like diabetes and cardiovascular diseases.

Public Health Surveillance Structure

In Andhra Pradesh, surveillance and epidemic monitoring operate under the Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme (IDSP) through:

• State Surveillance Unit (SSU): Based in Vijayawada, collects data, alerts districts.
• District Surveillance Units (DSU): In each of 26 districts, supervised by District Surveillance Officers.

At the national level, IDSP is managed by the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) and supported by ICMR for lab confirmation and outbreak investigation.

Key Stakeholders in Epidemic Management

1. Health & Family Welfare Department: Coordinates overall epidemic response.
2. IDSP: Maintains case reports, outbreak verification.
3. Local Bodies: Handle environmental control measures.
4. Public Health Engineering: Ensures clean water, chlorination (≥0.5 mg/L residual chlorine).
5. Food Safety Department: Investigates foodborne illnesses.
6. Animal Husbandry: Handles zoonoses (e.g., rabies, brucellosis).
7. Education Department: Supports school-based awareness and screenings.
8. Disaster Management Authority: Coordinates logistics and multi-sectoral response.
9. Police Department: Enforces quarantines, maintains law and order.
10. Information & PR Department: Manages public communication and risk messaging.

Steps in Epidemic Investigation

Investigation often starts retrospectively after the epidemic peak. A structured yet flexible approach includes:

1. Verification of Diagnosis

• Exclude spurious epidemics caused by mass hysteria or misreporting.
• Use clinical samples for laboratory confirmation.
• Example: A school outbreak perceived as food poisoning was identified as mass psychogenic illness due to no pathogen detection.

2. Confirmation of Epidemic

• Compare current case numbers with historical data.
• Confirm only if counts exceed expected levels significantly (≥2 SE).
• Lab testing is essential to rule out misdiagnosis (e.g., dengue).

3. Define Population at Risk

• Map area with landmarks, dwellings, and water sources.
• Count population using surveys and family records.
• Calculate attack rates using numerator (cases) and denominator (total population).

4. Rapid Case Search

• Conduct house-to-house or institutional surveys.
• Train workers to collect demographic, clinical, and exposure data.
• Continue daily case search for 2× incubation period after last case.

5. Data Analysis

• Use Time, Place, Person model:
  • Time: Epidemic curves to detect exposure timeline and type.
  • Place: Spot maps to locate clusters and sources.
  • Person: Analyze by age, sex, occupation to identify risk groups.

6. Formulation of Hypothesis

Include:

• Source of infection
• Causative agent
• Mode of spread
• Environmental factors

Example Hypothesis:
“Outbreak of diarrheal illness is likely caused by Vibrio cholerae, spread through contaminated well water (source), via fecal-oral route, exacerbated by poor sanitation and high temperatures.”

7. Testing Hypothesis

• Use analytical studies like case-control or cohort designs.
• Compute attack rates, odds ratios (OR), or relative risk (RR).
• Validate statistically significant associations.

8. Ecological Assessment

• Evaluate environmental and behavioral contributors.
• Example: Water pipeline breaks, milk supply contamination, climate, or vector population dynamics.

9. Further Investigation

• May include:
  • Medical exams
  • Screening
  • Lab testing (food, feces, blood)
  • Immunity checks

10. Report Writing

Structure the report with:

• Background
• Historical Data
• Methods
• Analysis
• Control Measures Taken

11. Public Communication

• Disseminate timely and transparent information using IEC strategies.
• Counter misinformation and panic.

12. Monitoring and Evaluation

• Continue surveillance to detect new cases.
• Evaluate effectiveness of control measures.
• Modify interventions based on real-time data.

13. Future Preparedness

• Document outbreak thoroughly.
• Strengthen infrastructure, surveillance systems.
• Recommend long-term measures (e.g., clean water supply, routine vaccination).

Operational Research in Epidemics

Operational research (OR) supports real-time, data-driven decision-making during epidemics.

Objectives of OR:

• Identify gaps and bottlenecks.
• Improve response time and resource allocation.
• Test innovative solutions in the field.

Examples:

• SMS-Based Reporting: Reduced reporting time from 4.5 days to 1 day.
• ORS Leaflets: Increased correct ORS use from 68% to 92%.
• Cholera Vaccine Study: Identified barriers like fear of side effects and suggested evening sessions.

Common Challenges

• Delayed reporting
• Misdiagnosis
• Community rumors
• Poor lab infrastructure
• Lack of trained epidemiologists

---

Conclusion

Epidemic investigation is a cornerstone of public health response. A multi-disciplinary, intersectoral approach involving surveillance, scientific methods, community engagement, and operational research ensures effective control and future preparedness. Structured investigation backed by real-time data analysis helps not only to contain current outbreaks but also to build resilient health systems.

MCQs

1. An epidemic is statistically considered to exist when the number of cases exceeds:

A. 1 standard deviation above mean
B. 1.5 times the previous year’s cases
C. 2 standard deviations above the mean
D. 10% of the total population

Correct Answer: C. 2 standard deviations above the mean

2. Which type of epidemic has a sharp rise and fall in the epidemic curve?

A. Continuous common source
B. Point source epidemic
C. Propagated epidemic
D. Slow epidemic

Correct Answer: B. Point source epidemic

3. A propagated epidemic is characterized by:

A. A single peak
B. Flat epidemic curve
C. Multiple waves of cases
D. Sudden end to the outbreak

Correct Answer: C. Multiple waves of cases

4. Which of the following is an example of a slow epidemic?

A. Cholera
B. Food poisoning
C. Measles
D. Type 2 Diabetes

Correct Answer: D. Type 2 Diabetes

5. Which department ensures safe drinking water supply during outbreaks like cholera?

A. Food Safety Department
B. Health & Family Welfare
C. Public Health Engineering Department
D. Animal Husbandry

Correct Answer: C. Public Health Engineering Department

6. In an epidemic investigation, calculating attack rates requires:

A. Numerator only
B. Denominator only
C. Both numerator and denominator
D. Only total population

Correct Answer: C. Both numerator and denominator

7. What is the minimum residual chlorine recommended in drinking water during an epidemic?

A. 0.1 mg/L
B. 0.25 mg/L
C. 0.5 mg/L
D. 1.0 mg/L

Correct Answer: C. 0.5 mg/L

8. Mass hysteria among students after a meal with no lab-confirmed pathogen is an example of:

A. Propagated epidemic
B. Zoonotic epidemic
C. Spurious epidemic
D. Continuous source outbreak

Correct Answer: C. Spurious epidemic

9. The correct order of initial steps in epidemic investigation is:

A. Data analysis → Hypothesis testing → Diagnosis
B. Verification of diagnosis → Confirmation of epidemic → Define population at risk
C. Hypothesis → Testing → Case search
D. Case search → Data analysis → Diagnosis

Correct Answer: B. Verification of diagnosis → Confirmation of epidemic → Define population at risk

10. What type of study is commonly used for hypothesis testing during an outbreak?

A. Descriptive survey
B. Ecological study
C. Case-control or cohort study
D. Cross-sectional study

Correct Answer: C. Case-control or cohort study

11. Which department handles vector control measures such as fogging and spraying?

A. Education Department
B. Local Bodies (Panchayats/Municipalities)
C. Disaster Management Authority
D. Food Safety Department

Correct Answer: B. Local Bodies (Panchayats/Municipalities)

12. In a spot map during an epidemic, what kind of information is analyzed?

A. Temporal trend
B. Age and gender
C. Geographic distribution of cases
D. Epidemic curve shape

Correct Answer: C. Geographic distribution of cases

13. The outbreak curve of a mixed epidemic typically shows:

A. Constant flat pattern
B. Sharp initial peak followed by secondary waves
C. Only one sharp peak
D. Slow progressive rise

Correct Answer: B. Sharp initial peak followed by secondary waves

14. Which national institute provides laboratory support through its virology labs (VRDLs)?

A. NCDC
B. AIIMS
C. ICMR
D. WHO

Correct Answer: C. ICMR

15. The role of the Education Department in an epidemic includes:

A. Testing water samples
B. Conducting vaccinations in schools
C. Enforcing lockdowns
D. Managing health center referrals

Correct Answer: B. Conducting vaccinations in schools

16. Which of the following best defines Operational Research (OR) in epidemics?

A. Experimental study on lab animals
B. Theoretical modeling of diseases
C. Field-level research to improve epidemic response
D. Legislative drafting for health laws

Correct Answer: C. Field-level research to improve epidemic response

17. A valid hypothesis in an epidemic should NOT include:

A. Source of infection
B. Causative agent
C. Economic cost of epidemic
D. Environmental factors

Correct Answer: C. Economic cost of epidemic

18. Which analytical tool provides clues about time-related trends in an epidemic?

A. Spot map
B. Pie chart
C. Epidemic curve
D. Flowchart

Correct Answer: C. Epidemic curve

19. Common challenge NOT typically faced during epidemics:

A. Delayed reporting
B. Misdiagnosis
C. Availability of trained epidemiologists
D. Community misinformation

Correct Answer: C. Availability of trained epidemiologists